In this scene, Ava and her boyfriend, Jack, have already agreed to a game of “giver’s choice.” Jack has just given Ava his choice for her: His head between her legs and his tongue working non-stop until she is moaning in ecstasy. We pick up the scene as Ava considers what sexual fun she can “give” back to Jack after his cunnilingus gave her an amazing orgasm.

-----

I can experience multiple orgasms, and I know that Jack was prepared to have his tongue in my pussy for as many orgasms as I wanted, but I had to recover a bit, and, well, I was intensely hot with that night’s idea of “giving something to him.” So I asked him to come back up and lie behind me, caressing my tits while I recovered. He slid himself up behind me and put his arms around me again. I turned my head back and gave him a long kiss as he once again caressed my tits. I reached down and felt his cock. It was not soft, but it wasn’t very hard. It was then that I knew what I was going to do.

I squeezed his cock and rubbed the head against my ass. As he got harder, I slid his cock between the cheeks of my ass and slid it up and down, from the small of my back to the base of my pussy. It didn’t take long before he was hard. I was trying to make him wonder if we were going to do it doggy style or whether we were going to have anal sex. I slid his hard cock up the crease of my ass and pressed it further in until it was pressed against my anus. I then rubbed it up and down against my anus. This got him not just hard but rock hard. It was at this point that I turned back and said, “I think that cock belongs in my ass. What do you think?” He answered, “Oh, I think it belongs deep in your ass.”

I replied, “Is that a promise?” and then slid his cock out and stroked it hard for a bit. I felt the head of his cock and there was a good amount of pre-cum dripping out. I should explain at this point that Jack knew exactly what I was doing. I can relax easily enough and Jack has enough pre-cum available that I don’t need any lubricant for anal sex. His own juices are generally more than enough lubricant for me. So that’s what I was doing. I squeezed his cock and then spread his fluid all over the head and entrance to my ass. It was good and slippery. I then pressed my body back against his cock and, using my hand, slowly slid him into my ass.

If he thrusts hard into me at this point, it hurts like hell, and this is why communication and gentleness are so important in anal sex. We had worked through anal sex long before, so Jack knew what to do. With the head of his cock in my ass, he would gently thrust in and out just a little bit. While he’s doing this, I’m concentrating on completely relaxing my muscles. When I’m feeling more comfortable, I press against him. At this point, we’re pretty much good to go, and he firmly but gently grabs my hips with his hands and slides his cock deeper into my ass. He doesn’t do it all at once, but rather through rhythmic thrusting, in and out, in and out, a little further inside me each time. Eventually, I can feel him all the way inside me, and he’s always extremely hard. It is a totally hot and sexy process that takes time. The key is total trust, because if there is any impatience on his part, I end up in pain.

Tonight, he pushed all the way in and stayed there. He reached his hand around and started to caress my pussy with his fingers while his cock was in my ass. How can you not love that feeling? It got even better when he slid two fingers inside my pussy while his cock was in my ass. I helped by squeezing my ass muscles around his cock while he slid his fingers in and out of my pussy. God, he was so hard and filled me up so much. The great thing about anal sex isn’t the pleasure of having a guy’s cock in your ass; that really doesn’t have any kind of pleasurable sensation attached to it for me. It’s the feeling of being full, of being totally penetrated by hard cock. I don’t care where it is inside me—my mouth, my pussy, or my ass—there is nothing better than having a hard cock deep inside me. Jack has a large cock, and in this instance I was definitely feeling it.

At this point, I knew exactly what I wanted. I wanted him to fuck my ass while I reached between my legs and masturbated, with his balls swinging against my fingers. So I whispered, “Fuck me now, and don’t stop.” I spread my legs as Jack grabbed my hip with his free hand (we were still on our sides). I reached down and felt his wonderful balls as he pulled out a little bit and started thrusting into me. His balls were tight and I laid my hand against them as Jack slid his cock in and out of my ass. I started to masturbate.

This to me is the real payoff of anal sex: Your partner is totally getting off, you physically feel him entirely connected to you, you are bringing pleasure to yourself (often with his help), with the added bonus of having his balls every once in a while slapping against your fingertips.

It wasn’t very long before I heard Jack start to groan. I said to him, “Oh yeah, come in my ass,” knowing that this would drive him crazy. Besides, I like having him come in my ass. I can really feel his orgasm that way. With his thighs pressed against your own ass, you feel his muscles tense while his cock throbs inside you. It is so hot. Jack started thrusting deep and slow, each one bringing him closer to orgasm. With a final groan, I felt him press deep inside me, his thigh muscles tensed against my ass. With him relaxing after his orgasm but his cock still hard inside my ass, I masturbated faster and faster. I can’t explain the feeling at all, but having an orgasm with a cock in your ass does feel really good, so I shouldn’t say the experience of anal sex doesn’t give any physical pleasure to a woman.

Jack squeezed my hip. “Oh God, I love that. When you come with my cock in your ass, all your muscles tense, and it’s like this one last shudder as you squeeze my cock.”

He slid out and I rolled over. We kissed and then held each other close for a while. “You’re amazing,” he said.

“No, you’re amazing,” I said. This is going to sound totally arrogant, but we were both right.