The Game ... First Time Sex: Part 17 - Pillow Talk

The anticipation causes me to be flushed with a warm, exhilarating feeling. Donna moves Marcus on the blanket-covered couch and removes the towel. Tonya sets me down next to Marcus on the same couch. I notice that this seems a bit choreographed, but I'm not complaining. Donna gets between Marcus legs and moves his knees apart. She licks down Marcus' neck, nipples, down his stomach, and takes his balls into her mouth. Tonya does the exact same thing to me. As if cued, they both insert our hard dicks into their mouths as we lay our heads on the back of the couch. We haven't been allowed to reciprocate up to this point, but once again, I'm not complaining. They suck us generously and seem to be in no hurry. So far, it seems like the beginning of a long evening similar to Friday and Saturday nights, but there is more to come.

Slowly, Donna sits up, and Tonya lifts her lips off my dick and sits up too. Marcus and I want to start working on them, but we are stopped by Donna's announcement.

"Tonight, we present you with a gift. We will enjoy giving you this gift as a tribute and payback for what you have given us in the past," says Donna with a fake formality.

"Yes. You guys have given us a lot, and we want to fill you up with the same feeling as we have gotten in the past," says Tonya.

I'm thinking that this sounds so thoughtful, but on the other hand we may be getting set up for something, but I'm not quite sure which it will be. Marcus looks at me, and I know that he has the same feeling as we await opening the presents.

Donna says, "It's time to open your presents."

Marcus and I unwrap the gifts that Tamara bought and gave to Donna and Tonya Sunday morning just before we left. Holy shit! We see two identical, strap-on dildos.

"What the Fuuuck?" exclaims Marcus.

I'm stunned too and repeat Marcus' words, "I agree. What the fuck?"

"These are for you guys," says Donna.

"You want us to wear these things?" asks Marcus.

"Not exactly," says Tonya.

"Then what?" I say trying to figure out what the hell we need with strap-on dildos.

"I said they were for you guys," says Donna.

Suddenly, I catch on. Marcus doesn't have a clue, yet.

"I think I don't like where this is going," I say.

Tonya laughs, "You may be right. You may not like where these are going."

"Fuuuuck," says Marcus suddenly aware of the pun.

Tonya and Donna quickly strap on the false dicks while Marcus, and I are speechless as we stare at them.

"You guys get on your knees and bend over the couch," says Donna.

"You're not gonna stick those up things up our asses, are you?" asks Marcus.

"I don't think you had any problem sticking yours up ours, Mr. Rear Entry Marcus," says Tonya enjoying his astonishment.

"This is my worst nightmare," I say feeling like I'm on death row.

"I said bend over," commands Donna.

"Be gentle. This is my first time," says Marcus trying to be funny and starting to accept the idea that we don't have a choice.

"I can go with that. Be gentle," I say.

"Do these dicks look as big as yours?" asks Donna.

"No, not at all. Of course not," I say.

"And do you think that your asses are bigger or smaller than Tonya's and mine?" asks Donna.

Well, there is no way that I'm going to say that their asses are bigger than ours, so that answer is predetermined, "Bigger."

"So, what's the problem?" asks Tonya.

"Is this an essay question or multiple choice?" asks Marcus.

"I think we'll pass the exam whatever we answer," I say.

Donna can't resist the last jab, "And remember the Godsmack lyrics, 'And I'd only do for you what you'd do for me?'"

"Oh geezus," says Marcus coming to the realization that this is really going to happen.

"No sense getting religion now," I laugh uneasily.

Donna puts a condom on each dildo and lubes it up generously. Then Tonya sticks her lubed finger up my ass, and Donna does the same to Marcus. Marcus and I both cringe, and this is just their little fingers.

"Ready?" asks Donna.

"If I say no would it make any difference?" I ask while accepting our fate.

"Absolutely not," says Tonya getting a kick out of our protests.

"Just make sure the condom doesn't break. I don't want to get pregnant," say Marcus.

"A comedian to the end," I manage to laugh.

"Yes, and you're getting it in the end," says Donna enjoying our plight.

There will be no pardon, exemptions, or reprieve from this death sentence. The girls align themselves behind us and proceed to inch their way into us. Oh fucking geezus. What the hell? This is agony. This is a first for Marcus and me for sure. At first they do a quick inch in and out a couple of times. Suddenly, I feel the whole gawd damn thing inside of me. I feel unbearable pressure inside of me. I think I'm gonna die. They get a rhythm going, and I know I'm fucked.

After only thirty seconds of this drill, Marcus starts yelling, "Take it out. Take it out."

Donna is laughing and removes it slowly enjoying Marcus' uneasy feeling. Marcus turns over showing a limp dick, but Tonya keeps going in and out of me.

"I don't mind if you remove mine too," I hint hoping for relief from this torture.

"This isn't over," says Donna.

While Marcus gets a temporary reprieve from his anus agony, Donna slips under me and sucks my limp dick while Tonya holds the dildo as far as she can push it inside of me. I manage to get hard. While I enjoy Donna's mouth on my dick, the feeling is counteracted by the dildo inside of me. Tonya makes a few more in and out motions and pulls out as Donna takes my dick out of her mouth. I turn around and sit on the couch feeling a terrible enema effect.

"Next?" Donna commands Marcus.

"I'm good," laughs Marcus.

"Not an option," says Donna.

Marcus reluctantly bends over the couch once again and holds himself up with his hands. Donna puts some more lube on the condom-covered dildo and slides it into Marcus. Tonya slips under Marcus and sucks his completely limp dick. He gets hard, and Donna starts pumping vigorously.

Tonya stops sucking Marcus, and comes back to me, "Your turn."

I bend over and Tonya plunges into me once again. I am dying, fucking dying. My dick is only half hard.

Suddenly, Marcus yells in an alarming voice, "Take it out. Take it out now!"

"OK, Mr. Rockstar," says Donna and pulls it out fast and without mercy leaving the condom stuck half way up his ass.

"I've gotta go," says Marcus as he pulls the condom out and runs to the basement bathroom.

As Tonya pulls her dido out of me I say, "Me too."

I hold my towel tight around my waist and run two flights upstairs to my bathroom. I hear the girls laughing uncontrollably in the background. Tonya takes off the strap-on dildo and follows me upstairs and waits in the bedroom.

As I flush the toilet, Tonya asks through the closed door to my bath, "Are you OK?"

"Yeah. I think so. I never knew how you could take that," I say.

"Not so bad?" she says.

"Not so bad? I am dying. Let's not add that to our routine from now on if it's OK with you," I plead.

"Maybe every once in a while to keep you in line," she teases.

"I promise to keep in line forever," I say.

"I'm gonna shower and be back down in a minute," I say through the door.

"I'll wait," she says in a concerned voice.

After I quickly but thoroughly clean up in the shower, we return to the basement together, and I see Marcus with Donna.

"No more of that shit," he says.

"I agree," I say.

"Oh fuuuck. Be right back," Marcus says and runs to the bathroom once again.

I join the girls in laughing this time since it's not me with the ass-agony, enema effect. A couple minutes later I hear Marcus in the shower for the second time.

"You want to join him this time?" I ask Donna.

"Nah, I want to do it out here," she laughs.

Marcus finally emerges with a towel wrapped around his waist. In fact we are all draped in towels. Marcus and I aren't so quick to initiate any further action for the moment. I can still feel the residual effects of the dildo.

"Fuuuuck that shit," says Marcus as Donna and Tonya laugh at him.

"So, how does it feel to lose your virginity?" asks Tonya.

"I feel so violated and abused," Marcus laughs as he cuffs his hands over his face while faking a sobbing cry, and I can see he is returning back to normal.

"I understand completely," I add.

"I think it was exciting," says Donna.

"We have more condoms," laughs Tonya.

"I'm good," I say.

"I can wait too," says Marcus.

We all laugh and my ass is returning to normal, somewhat. I just want to fuck now really bad in order to forget the last few minutes. Earlier, I was thinking about fucking Tonya in my bed, but I am turned on with all the excitement and want to monitor Donna and Marcus, so Tonya and I stay in the basement.

"Happy Valentine's Day," says Donna.

We move to the other side of the room and I lower my voice to a whisper as I say to Tonya, "Happy Valentine's Day."

"Happy Valentine's Day," she says as I kiss her deeply.

"We weren't trying to hurt you guys," she whispers to me.

"I know. I can appreciate how that feels now. Like I said, I never knew how you guys are able to do that. I waited until I thought you wanted to do it, but Marcus did it to you first, so I never got to ask you if it was OK. I just did it since you let Marcus," I explain.

"You weren't jealous were you?" she asks showing a little concern.

"No. Absolutely not. It wasn't something that I had to do first with you. I was first where it counted, and that always excites me when I think about it," I say looking back at our first time together.

"The first time that I was with you, my heart was pounding so fast, and I was so scared," she admits.

I am a bit astonished at her recollection because she seemed so relaxed.

"You were?" I asked, "I wouldn't have known it. You seemed so calm. Gosh, you turned me on when I first saw you, and then my heart was pounding too when you hiked your skirt up to let me see your panties. And you kissed me deeper than I had ever, ever felt before."

"Donna prepared me well, and I went over and over what it would be like and how I would respond. It turned out wonderful," she recalls.

"I know. I was there," I smile and start kissing her.

On the other couch, Donna is licking Marcus from head to toe trying to make up for the surprise rear entry job she did on him. His dick is sticking up elevated to its usual position, so I know he has recovered. He reverses positions with her and slips between her legs to suck her pussy.

I don't expect any special treatment other than what Tonya normally gives me, but she initiates the first moves. I indulge her aggression and lie back as she massages my knees and works her way to my feet. I feel so relaxed as I feel her tongue edge up from the top of one foot, up my shin, across my knee, inside of my thigh, and finally to my balls after a few minutes. First she licks one and then the other, and then she takes both into her mouth. I reach down and run my fingers through her hair. Her long strands feel so good as I feel her tongue run up and down my dick. I love watching her in the dim, candle-lit room. As Tonya takes my dick in her mouth, Donna is sucking Marcus' dick too. I feel that the girls are doting on us.

After we change positions, I lick Tonya from her toes to her neck, and Marcus does the same for Donna. Donna gets on top of Marcus and squats down on his dick while Marcus lies back with his fingers clasped behind his head. Donna loves to do that to Marcus. Tonya turns me over and does the same for me. I love it. It's a lot of work squatting on top like that, but she is great.

After I while Tonya lies next to me, and I watch Donna snuggle next to Marcus.

"We got hours before my parents return," I say.

"There is more to come," teases Donna.

Donna raises up, "We have another request."

Marcus comes out of his trance, "Fuuuck. No more dildos, please."

"Tonya wants to do what we did when she was gone before Thanksgiving. Remember, when we went to her house when she was gone?" explains Donna.

"I remember it well," I say.

"Me too," says Marcus suddenly more cooperative.

"You guys sit on the couch together," commands Donna.

Marcus and I sit on the couch and watch Donna peel the wrapping off of a condom and then she slowly rolls down Marcus' dick.

Donna motions for me to lie on a blanket on the floor. Tonya straddles on top of me.

"Marcus, get behind her," commands Donna and Marcus gets on his knees behind Tonya.

As Tonya eases down on my dick I lift my pelvis and push upward into her as Marcus pushes his dick in from the rear. Together, Marcus and I work our dicks in and out of Tonya while Donna watches. As I continue pushing upward, Marcus moves in and out from the rear.

After a few minutes, Donna says, "OK that's enough," and touches Marcus' shoulders with her hands, and he pulls out.

"OK Rockstar, let's get that shield off," she says to Marcus as she pulls the condom off his dick.

Tonya lies straight down on me and rests for a minute, and I kiss her neck. As Donna takes Marcus to the couch across the room, and they start kissing, I turn Tonya over and spread her legs. I've been wanting to do this since we came to the basement, so I ease my head between her legs and insert my tongue far into her pussy. She spreads her bent knees far apart and relaxes as I rotate my tongue round and round inside her pussy. I never get tired of doing that for her.

I edge my tongue down her right left thigh and back up to her pussy very, very slowly. Then I move my tongue up her stomach to her left nipple and then to her right. Ever so slowly I move my tongue to her neck as I ease my dick into her pussy until the base of it is pressing hard against her lips. I lift up and lick her nipples left and right as I ease in and out of her pussy. Every once in a while she squeezes my dick with her Kegel muscle and I make my dick throb inside of her.

Marcus is licking Donna's knee and spreads her legs far apart. I see his head between her legs as she holds her pussy lips wide apart with her fingers. When Marcus inserts his tongue into her pussy, she releases and take her fingers and gently strokes the back of his neck. Then she runs her fingernails down his back and does a spider crawl from the small of his back down to each ass cheek. He edges his knees upward between hers and inserts his dick into her pussy as he sucks her left nipple.

Minutes go by and the candles continue their warm, romantic glow as they bounce shadows off the walls and around the room. I feel Tonya grabbing my sides, so I slow down but it does no good. Tonya's exhilaration peaks and she doesn't want me to stop so I lick her neck and pump in and out. I feel my temples tingling and the backs of my calves numbing at the same time that all of my body flushes with sensation. I don't hold back and shot after shot of cum fills Tonya's pussy as she pumps with me. I don't slow down because the feeling just won't stop tonight. Tonya continues grabbing me and pumping, and I don't let her down as long as she wants it.

Marcus stays on top of Donna, and they are working their pelvises firmly against each other. Donna has her mouth firmly on Marcus' neck as they pump and pump. As I slow down my pace with Tonya, I see Marcus doing the same. In and out, I slow the pace. Never, never do I pull out suddenly or fast after I come. After Tonya completely relaxes and rests her arms by her sides, I ease my dick out and move down and kiss and lick her pussy. Marcus' head is firmly between Donna's legs too. Soon, he raises up and kisses Donna. Later, we dress. Donna and Tonya drop Marcus off at his house. Tonya calls when she gets to her bed, and we say goodnight over the webcam.

It's been a great Valentine's weekend. Music, lingerie shopping, Opaque restaurant, flowers, pillow fight, and the best feelings that Tonya and I as well as Donna and Marcus can experience with each other. Please read chapter 18 to continue the story. We are off to Las Vegas for Trish and Donnie's wedding next. As always, I appreciate your taking time to read about my life and appreciate your feedback.